Oscars 2012 – The Verdict
Definitely not a vintage year. Look at the titles and ask yourself how many of them you are going to want to watch in 10 or 20 years time. Not many – if any.
I really enjoyed The Artist, twice, but apart from being a celebration of cinema, is it memorable? But then why is Singin' In The Rain such a classic? I like The Descendants a lot – apart from the title – but it's a very good film rather than special. And then look at the rest.
Yes, Meryl probably deserved to win for The Iron Lady, though I feel sorry for Viola Davis, but the film itself is little more than a vehicle for a One Woman Show. Though I do think Christopher Plummer is the right man for Best Supporting Actor for Beginners – maybe some people will start watching it now.
But to give Woody Allen an Oscar for the lazily-scripted Midnight in Paris is an insult to the other 4 contenders. And Hugo, although it cleaned up in the behind the scenes categories, is mainly a technical feat.
Having said all that, was 2011 a vintage year? I was a huge fan of The King's Speech, but that is not a Great Film, either. And the last Oscar-nominated Great Film – There Will Be Blood – 5 years ago, was overlooked in favour of No Country For Old Men, which wasn't as good as the Coen Bros's subsequent film, True Grit – which didn't win.
And so it goes, round and round, the treadmill of instant fame and celebrity, and then oblivion – very like The Artist, in fact. The Oscars are not really an indication of exceptional talent, just of temporary popularity under the disguise of Art. It's a glorified promotion campaign for movies which we all play along with, while pretending that we're too superior to care. But I bet you that Michel Hazanavicius and Jean Dujardin are extremely thrilled at being the first French guys to win Best Actor, Best Film and Best Director – without a word of French.
• Content supplied by the excellent Front Row Films website – check the site and join up for many more reviews and general all-round film goodness.
Must Reads
Joining The Circus
What to do for British politics?
Solidarity with Ukraine
Resource List
URL vs. IRL
Do DJs Today Need Social Media to Be Heard?
Trending track
I Hear (Borusiade Remix)
Mother of Mars
Shop NowMidnite Rogue
Hologram Teen
Shop Now